Critique, ahoy! This is, as usual, a great plush Rose here is one of my favourite background ponies, mainly because of her colour scheme, and you nailed that right off the bat (check!) As I said before, I love love love what you did with the ponytail, and it's still recognisable as Roseluck, which is good. Spot on. This is mostly a crit of your pattern (again!) but for my liking her 'plot' is a little out of proportion to her head - I wouln't stress about this too much, but it's something to look at. Just another thing - the closed eye seems to be a bit too close to her nose hehe I'd move it make a bit. Just one more thing - I'd put some stuffing in the ear. They look a bit flat hehe Even just some quilt batting or a teeny bit of stuffing would make it look a lot better. Again, awesome plush, and I hope to critique you again soon!
Well, the colouring is a bit good there. The big, happy, closed eye of Roseluck may add to the cuteness, or otherwise, 'HNNNNNG' factor. And the cutie mark is 90% accurate. The left line is too curved. You should had straightened the end more. And the plot! Hmmm...... its a bit out of proportion! Mmhmm. The rose on Roseluck's mane makes her look pretty and adorable. You know girls, hehe.... they like to decorate their hair and stuff.... I also guess the rose in her mane references to her cutie mark, does it? But! Would you mind if you add a little curvy line on the ear just like how the MLP:FIM illustrations and fan artists' artworks do? Did you miss that part by accident or purpose?
Anyways! (claps) not too bad! Your stars are at the right!
Sorry, I'm not that good at rating... (scratches head and smiles nervously)